Just like a lot of “My choice” critics, I thought of penning
down my thought. A lot has been said (Read Condemned); spoofs made, comments
made on Deepika’s personal life about her relationships/her declaration of
depression, that video is selling shampoos and fairness cream, elitist don’t
understand about feminism or empowerment as they are born with a silver spoon
etc etc etc…
It seems we were just waiting to pounce over the lady who
dare talk about empowerment, after all celebs are the easiest target. Looking at
the spoofs / My choice male version video, I am wondering people have so much
free time and government better do a good job employment generation.
I mean if you compare the stats for something disrespectful,
mocking and insensitive, I am left bewildered on our choices to protest …
- My Choice video – YouTube - 14 lac views in
approx a week with 13600 likes and 656 dislikes. Facebook - 70k+ likes and 5500
comments
- Hate speeches by our leaders – 9 lac views over
3 months duration. I couldn’t trace a facebook mention. (If someone finds it,
please one like from me).
- “Famous fevicol lyrics “main toh tandoori murgi
hun gataaka mujhe alcohol se” – 3.4 crore views in ~ 2 years with more likes
then dislikes on YouTube and many likes and groups on FB named as Fevicol se,
fevicol community etc (I too am party of tapping my feet on this number and am
ashamed of MY CHOICE here). I mean how much more can we objectify and commoditise
women in general. Where are we protesting against such creations when the small
kids are performing on this number and this song is being played loud in all
marriages and parties.
- JK Cement’s ad showing a bikini clad women with
33000 views – mixed reactions thankfully for this ad. But someone mentions that
this ad was targeted at the contractors/builders and sales grew by 36% post
this ad… Really?
I am still wondering what’s our choice of
protest? If at all we could raise voices against all the above and other similar
craps floating around, we could have moved the needle a bit. But, may be we think these ad makers just want to sell anything or who will take panga with politicians or ohh it's just a song,
isn’t it?
I may be sounding in absolute awe and support of My choice
Video and most of you must be closing this page to view other interesting
websites (Your choice).
Well, what I feel about this video I will share later but let’s look at a few aspects touched by the
video as I am still figuring was there
nothing to be praised for in this video?
To wear the clothes I
like – Being born and brought up in a Bihar town, I was over protected to
be home by 5pm, be fully covered from neck to toe be it inside house or outside
(preferably salwar suits and not even jeans). Reason safety, it’s a bad world
outside etc. I hardly found this act ever helped those men with their choice of groping and feeling the ladies on streets.
I and many others were robbed of our freedom to wear what we like. Of course a
few defied the norm and that gave the courage to rest to at least try. Bottom line – still we were robbed of our
choice and the freedom to wear clothes of our choice was missing. In fact,
there is still a huge section of our society which demands ladies under burqua
or long ghunghat. No one cares if these ladies are dying out of heat and perspiration
or getting rashes on face or simply feeling choked. It’s a culture, you are a
girl and you better live with this.
To be a size zero or
size 15 – “Next month is your
marriage and you better get in shape” … “why can’t you lose weight, you are
such an embarrassment”…. “you are over-weight please don’t wear jeans it looks
odd” … “I won’t go to the marriage as my cousins are all slim and I become the
butt of joke blahblahblah….
These statements are a household reality often hurled at the
women folks by men and women both (I bet on this one!). I may have health
issues which makes me fat, I may be leading a stressful life with little
support to focus on diet, I may have a broad built, but no you should be a
Sushmita Sen or Shilpa Shetty. I need not refer the many mentions of our
Bollywood actresses in news on their weight.
Thankfully awareness through fatshaming is brought to light
and people are recognizing to love their body (many are calling it a marketing
gimmick too, your choice again). I am fully in support of fitness and ensure we
are not overweight but let’s not make this a nightmare for a woman. Obesity
itself leads to depression and such constant mental stress for obesity is like
adding fuel to fire. It’s certainly my choice what size I want to be.
Marry or not to marry
– Highly debatable topic especially when Marriage defines a woman in many Asian
countries. An unmarried woman is a liability on her parents, usually outcast by
her community as no man found her suitable enough to marry and a bad influence
on the next generation. My wish to get into a commitment or be independent all
my life making my own choices and leading my life with a free will. What’s
wrong here if this is the voice of “My choice” video.
Sex before marriage
or outside of marriage or not have sex – no need for me to say anything
here as the word “Sex” itself is such a taboo. How could she so openly talk
about it, summoning prohibited actions like sex before or outside marriage?
As an individual yes I won’t support
sex outside marriage as it breaks the commitment between two individuals to be
loyal to each other. However, you don't know someone so don't judge until you know the background. A blanket statement of right or wrong does no service.
Sex before marriage is a very individual thing and those involved in it if are committed to stand by each other then what benefit are we getting in disapproving this.
However, my questions….
- -
Who looks after her choice when a married woman
is forced by her own husband/family into having sex with someone influential?
Isn’t that sex outside marriage that too forced one? If this is allowed or
prevalent then why a free will is so badly accused?
- -
What do you expect from a married women
abandoned (read… Chorhi hui aurat) by their husbands. They are abandoned for
myriad reasons including cheating/already married/remarriage/no visa support by
immigrant spouses/cant reproduce a boy…. Will she have any physical needs? How
should she fulfil those? She is married, no divorce filed and abandoned for the
rest of her life and she shouldn’t think of having sex outside marriage right? Maybe
she will force herself or be forced in flesh trade someday. There are 5163
exploitation/harassment cases in 17 ECR countries in last 3 years and over
25,000 women were abandoned in only one state in India by a 2007 estimate.
These ladies have no right to Sex I must say, as they are married with no
husband around. Bravo! These are those truths of life where it’s hard to say if
it’s right or wrong.
- -
Another interesting fact, under Indian law,
marital rape is not a crime even if it’s against the will of the victim. How
could you not have sex lady, I own you and your body (do hell with your spirit
and soul). As per NFHS 2005 data, 6590
per 1 lac women reported husbands physically forcing them for sex, out which
only 0.6% reported as per NCRB. Can we talk about this and condemn this all
across social media day in and day out or say these facts are screwed etc etc…
These
facts are not history and they are not pertaining to elitist. They are also not
one off instances.
Love temporarily or
lust forever – I won’t comment on this as I couldn’t understand the essence
behind this statement and hence I won’t sit and contemplate this. What I
understand in the literal sense, I won’t support this.
Love a man or woman
or both – Absolutely. Love is above your choice, religion, society,
tradition, social status… my inclination, my orientation towards gender will
decide my love for the same or the opposite sex.
Bindi, ring or
surname are ornaments, they can be
replaced but not love for you – Woman are tagged after marriage with
sindoor, bichiyaa (toe ring), choora (bangles) etc etc. Men – nothing. I know
this argument of mine sounds clichéd. But have you ever thought of what if they
don’t wear all this, does this make them less committed towards any
relationship? So why a choice of being a plain Jane woman without all this
razzmataaz. Again, this is for across the classes in society, who are
struggling to unshackle this chain.
Surname, my favourite topic. I mean I am Shobha Sinha for
20-25 years but after marriage I am suddenly Shobha Gupta. Not just this, there
are communities in India which change the first name of the bride too. So I was
Shobha Sinha and now I am Pooja Gupta. Do hell with my identity that existed
before my marriage. Those who say what’s in a name, please rethink what you are
saying.
Come at my time –
as a HR professional I have had so many conversations with parents/husband when
the female employees have to work late or in night shifts in last 10 years but the
answer mostly is no. Safety reason plus she is a girl and we won’t allow her so
much freedom. Even though the girl is capable and willing to stretch, sorry,
you are not allowed and she better be home by 6 (some lenient ones allow till
8). No choice here right?
To have your baby or
not, My songs your noise, my order your anarchy, your sins my virtues, I choose
to empathise or be indifferent .. I am different - Our definition is our
truth. Empowerment means differently to different individuals. If that’s not
matching with yours, fine, condemn it but don’t forget to appreciate what good
the person is trying to do.
Some went on to comment that a women of substance will never
approve of this video. Great minds are so well aware I tell you.
Well! A women of substance will assert that …
I agree to these "________" parts of the video as it attempts to raise a few deep scars on the womankind.
My apprehensions on
a few parts of the video as this will take us behind and not ahead. These parts
break the societal make, questions the humanity and will trigger insensitive
acts. My wish if the video could have spoken about education, freedom to
work, funeral rights for woman, be compassionate and leverage the feminine values balancing the masculine energy for a better world....
My appeal that let’s aspire for diversity and
equality. Bring about a place where the various genders thrive and strive for love, humility and respect. A place where women have a voice @ the dining table and @ the
boardroom table. A society where we support, nurture the women as they have a
loooooooong way to come up and claim their rights. Both men and women have to
come together to bring about a change as you can't clap with one hand. Also, aspire for a place where we don’t make
the male members feel the way we are feeling today or have felt for last many
years. Let’s not aim for matriarchy.
I am that women of substance and these are my views and my
choice. If 49% of women population assert and share their balanced view on the
My Choice Video, the makers will get a hint on what they should do probably
from next time.
Your choice to reject my views and continue the bashing or
pick up the best pieces of this video and promote to the fullest possible. Talk
of the positives and positivity will spread. Keep harping on the negative, we will remain miserable and not ever take any action.
Cheers, Jayshree
Aah, pls ignore the grammar, the write up is quite conversational without much of focus on sentence construct. And yes, am not a researcher though have tried capture a few facts online.